A Philosophical Inquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful

May 12, 2025

A Philosophical Inquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful

The next book we must write about on our blog is A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful by Edmund Burke (1757, second edition 1759), a seminal aesthetic treatise. As the first work to systematically distinguish the beautiful and the sublime as distinct rational categories, it marked a pivotal moment in philosophical thought. Burke’s ideas influenced prominent thinkers like Denis Diderot and Immanuel Kant and signalled a shift from the structured ideals of Neoclassicism to the emotive intensity of Romanticism. This essay explores Burke’s definitions of the beautiful and the sublime, their causal structures, and their lasting impact on philosophy and art.

Defining the Beautiful: Aesthetic Pleasure and Love

Burke’s concept of beauty centres on qualities that evoke pleasure and affection. He describes the beautiful as well-formed, delicate, and aesthetically pleasing. Unlike the sublime, which overwhelms, the beautiful invites gentle admiration and a sense of harmony. For Burke, the formal cause of beauty is the passion of love, which draws individuals toward objects that inspire tenderness. The material cause includes smallness, smoothness, and softness, as seen in delicate flowers or graceful forms.

Burke challenges traditional notions of beauty, particularly the Neoclassical emphasis on proportion. He argues, “Beauty hath usually been said to consist in certain proportions of parts. On considering the matter, I have great reason to doubt whether beauty is an idea belonging to proportion.” Instead, beauty arises from sensory and emotional responses, not mathematical precision. The efficient cause of beauty is calming the nerves, while its final cause is divine providence, reflecting God’s harmonious creation. This redefinition liberated aesthetics from rigid classical standards, paving the way for more subjective interpretations.

The Sublime: Power, Fear, and Awe

In contrast, Burke’s sublime is characterized by its ability to evoke awe, terror, and a sense of the infinite. The sublime compels and overwhelms, often through experiences of vastness or danger, such as towering mountains or stormy seas. Its formal cause is the passion of fear, particularly the fear of death, which heightens human awareness of mortality. The material cause includes vastness, obscurity, and magnificence, dwarfing human perception.

The efficient cause of the sublime is the tension of the nerves, a physiological response to overwhelming stimuli. Burke ties its final cause to a theological narrative, specifically God’s triumph over Satan, as depicted in John Milton’s Paradise Lost. This cosmic struggle imbues the sublime with divine power and mystery. By rooting the sublime in fear and grandeur, Burke distinguished it from the comforting nature of the beautiful, offering a framework that resonated with the emotional depth of Romanticism.

Causal Structures: A Philosophical Innovation

Burke’s analysis of the beautiful and the sublime is grounded in Aristotelian causation, comprising formal, material, efficient, and final causes. This systematic approach lends rigour to his aesthetic theory, making it both philosophical and accessible. For the beautiful, the interplay of love, delicate forms, nerve relaxation, and divine order creates a cohesive experience of pleasure. For the sublime, the combination of fear, vast forms, nerve tension, and divine conflict generates a thrilling encounter with the infinite.

This causal framework is particularly innovative because it detaches beauty and the sublime from traditional criteria like proportion, fitness, or perfection. Burke’s insistence that beauty is not tied to symmetry or utility challenged Neoclassical dogma. At the same time, his view of the sublime as a visceral, fear-driven experience introduced a new dimension to aesthetics. His ideas encouraged artists and thinkers to explore emotional and sensory extremes, influencing the Romantic emphasis on individuality and the natural world.

From Neoclassicism to Romanticism

Burke’s preference for the sublime over the beautiful reflects a broader cultural shift from Neoclassicism to Romanticism. Neoclassicism valued order, balance, and classical ideals, often prioritizing the beautiful as an expression of proportion and harmony. In contrast, Romanticism celebrated emotion, imagination, and the awe-inspiring power of nature, aligning closely with Burke’s sublime. His treatise provided a philosophical foundation for this transition, inspiring artists like J.M.W. Turner, whose paintings of stormy seas and vast landscapes embody the sublime’s grandeur.

By emphasizing the emotional impact of the sublime, Burke validated the Romantic fascination with the wild and the unknown. His work also influenced literary figures like Samuel Taylor Coleridge, whose poetry often explores themes of mystery and terror. The Enquiry thus served as a bridge between two eras, reshaping how society understood beauty and awe.

Burke’s Legacy in Aesthetics and Beyond

Burke’s Enquiry remains a cornerstone of aesthetic philosophy, offering insights that continue to resonate. His distinction between the beautiful and the sublime provided a vocabulary for analyzing human responses to art and nature, influencing fields from literature to psychology. Thinkers like Kant built on Burke’s ideas, refining the sublime as a concept tied to the limits of human reason. Meanwhile, Diderot praised the Enquiry's originality, cementing its place in Enlightenment discourse.

His work reminds us that aesthetics is not merely about pleasure but about grappling with the full spectrum of human emotion.

The treatise’s emphasis on sensory and emotional experience also anticipates modern aesthetic theories, prioritizing subjective perception over objective standards. In contemporary contexts, Burke’s sublime can be seen in cinematic depictions of cosmic vastness or natural disasters, while his beautiful informs minimalist design and harmonious art. His work reminds us that aesthetics is not merely about pleasure but about grappling with the full spectrum of human emotion.

A Timeless Exploration of Human Experience

Edmund Burke’s A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful is a landmark in philosophy and aesthetics. By distinguishing the beautiful from the sublime and grounding them in causal structures, Burke offered a nuanced understanding of human responses to art and nature. His rejection of proportion as the basis of beauty and his emphasis on fear and awe in the sublime challenged conventional wisdom, paving the way for Romanticism and modern aesthetics. As we continue to explore the interplay of beauty and terror, Burke’s insights remain a powerful lens for understanding the complexities of society and the human condition.

Read more »

A Detailed Exploration of Samuel Johnson’s A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland and the Rambler Press Edition

May 03, 2025

A Detailed Exploration of Samuel Johnson’s A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland and the Rambler Press Edition

Samuel Johnson’s A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland, first published in 1775, stands as a seminal work of travel literature, offering a vivid and introspective account of his 83-day expedition through Scotland in the late summer and autumn of 1773. Accompanied by his friend and future biographer James Boswell, Johnson, then 63 years old, embarked on this journey with a keen eye for observation and a mind attuned to the cultural, social, and natural landscapes of a region that was, at the time, relatively unfamiliar to many English readers. The book captures the physical journey and Johnson’s reflections on the Scottish Highlands, its people, and their way of life, filtered through his characteristic wit, intellectual rigour, and moral insight. The Rambler Press edition of this work, a limited and exquisitely crafted publication, brings Johnson’s narrative to life with a reverence for 18th-century printing traditions, making it a collector’s treasure and a fitting tribute to the literary giant.

The Historical and Literary Context of Johnson’s Journey

Samuel Johnson, a towering figure of 18th-century English literature, was already an established literary critic, poet, essayist, and lexicographer when he undertook his Scottish journey. Best known for his A Dictionary of the English Language (1755) and his essays in The Rambler and The Idler, Johnson was a man of profound intellect and curiosity. His decision to travel to Scotland in 1773 was motivated by a desire to explore a region that, despite its proximity to England, was culturally and geographically distinct. The Act of Union in 1707 had politically united England and Scotland, but the Highlands remained a place of mystery and intrigue, often romanticized or misunderstood by outsiders. The Jacobite risings, notably the 1745 rebellion led by Bonnie Prince Charlie, had left a lasting impression on the English imagination. Johnson’s journey came when the Highlands underwent significant social and economic changes, including the aftermath of the Highland Clearances.

Johnson’s companion, James Boswell, a young Scottish lawyer and aspiring writer, played a crucial role in the journey. Boswell, who would later achieve fame with his Life of Samuel Johnson (1791), was eager to introduce Johnson to his homeland. The two men set out from Edinburgh in August 1773, travelling through the Lowlands before venturing into the rugged terrain of the Highlands and the Hebrides. Their journey was not without challenges—Johnson, who suffered from poor health and was unaccustomed to such arduous travel, often complained about the harsh conditions. At the same time, Boswell’s more youthful energy and familiarity with Scotland provided a counterbalance. The resulting book, A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland, is a testament to Johnson’s ability to transform personal experience into universal insight, blending detailed observations with philosophical musings on human nature, progress, and tradition.

Themes and Observations in the Text

Johnson’s narrative is structured as a series of letters or essays, each focusing on a particular place or theme encountered during the journey. He begins with his arrival in Edinburgh, commenting on the city’s architecture, history, and intellectual life, before moving on to the Highlands and the Hebrides, including visits to islands like Skye, Mull, and Iona. Throughout the text, Johnson displays a deep interest in the Scottish people's social customs, economic conditions, and historical traditions. He is particularly struck by the stark contrast between the romanticized image of the Highlands and the harsh realities of life there, including poverty, depopulation, and the decline of the clan system.

One of the most striking aspects of the book is Johnson’s critique of the Highland way of life. He expresses scepticism about the idealized notion of the noble savage, a popular concept in 18th-century literature, and instead highlights the practical challenges faced by the Highlanders, such as their reliance on a subsistence economy and their vulnerability to external pressures. At the same time, Johnson is not without sympathy; he admires the resilience and hospitality of the people he meets, even as he questions the sustainability of their traditions in the face of modernization. Though not as detailed as modern historians might wish, his reflections on the Highland Clearances reveal an awareness of the social upheaval occurring in the region, as landlords began evicting tenants to make way for sheep farming.

Johnson also devotes considerable attention to the natural landscape of Scotland, describing its rugged beauty with a mixture of awe and trepidation. His descriptions of the Hebrides, with their stark cliffs and turbulent seas, are particularly evocative, capturing the sublime quality of the landscape that would later inspire the Romantic poets. Yet Johnson’s prose is grounded in a rational, Enlightenment sensibility—he is more interested in understanding the world than losing himself in its beauty. This balance between observation and analysis makes A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland such a compelling read, even for modern audiences.

The Rambler Press Edition: A Work of Art

The Rambler Press edition of A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland elevates Johnson’s text into a collector’s item, meticulously crafted to reflect the aesthetic and printing traditions of the 18th century. Limited to a circulation of just 25 copies, this edition is a testament to the artistry and dedication of small-press publishing. The book is set in Monotype Bell and Monotype Bulmer fonts, both popular in Great Britain during the late 1780s, shortly after the original publication of Johnson’s work. These fonts, with their elegant serifs and balanced proportions, evoke the typographic style of the period, providing a visual connection to the time in which Johnson wrote.

The choice of paper further enhances the tactile and visual experience of the book. Printed on Fabriano Tiepolo 130 g cotton paper, the pages have a luxurious texture and a subtle off-white tone that complements the historical feel of the edition. Fabriano Tiepolo, known for its high quality and durability, is a fitting choice for a book of this calibre, ensuring that the text is presented in a beautiful and enduring way. The volume consists of 240 pages, formatted in a compact yet elegant 165x250 mm size, making it a pleasure to handle and read.

The binding of the Rambler Press edition is another highlight, showcasing the skill of bookbinder Magdalena Bulanda. Each copy is handmade in half leather, a style typical of fine bindings from the 18th century, and comes with a protective case to ensure its longevity. The edges of the book block are coloured by 18th-century fashion, adding a final touch of authenticity to the design. Together, these elements create a volume that is not only a faithful reproduction of Johnson’s work but also a work of art in its own right, appealing to bibliophiles and scholars alike.

A Lasting Legacy

Samuel Johnson’s A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland remains a significant work in the canon of English literature, offering a window into a pivotal moment in Scottish history and a glimpse of Johnson’s formidable intellect at work. The Rambler Press edition, with its limited run and exquisite craftsmanship, honours the legacy of this text by presenting it in a form that reflects the elegance and sophistication of the 18th century. From the choice of fonts to the handmade binding, every detail of this edition has been carefully considered, making it a fitting tribute to Johnson’s enduring contribution to travel literature. For those fortunate enough to own one of the 25 copies, this edition is not just a book but a piece of history, bridging the gap between the 18th century and the present day.

Read more »